There is a particular kind of quiet that settles over Old Trafford when the window shuts and the club has done, well, basically nothing. Not the calm of a job finished; it’s the dead-eyed silence of a kitchen that ran out of ingredients mid-service, then decided the solution was to “simplify the menu.”
That is where INEOS have parked Manchester United again. No meaningful January strengthening, while the squad is already painfully thin. It feels eerily familiar, because we have watched this movie before. Last year, the same decision, the same shrug, the same insistence that “the group” is enough, even after shipping attackers out on loan and asking Ruben Amorim to make goals out of vibes and good intentions.
A football club does not run on intentions. It runs on bodies, healthy legs, options off the bench, and the grim reality that a season is a long road with potholes. Injuries happen, form dips, suspensions land, and the fixture list turns into a weekly interrogation. Right now, United’s margin for error is thin enough to read through. One tweak, one knock, one bad ten minutes, and suddenly you are looking at a bench that feels like a youth tournament. That is not “trusting the project.” That is leaving the project out in the rain and acting surprised when it warps.
And here is the part that should keep the decision makers awake. If United claw their way back into Europe next year, whether it’s the UEFA Champions League or the Europa League, the club is setting itself up for a summer window that has to be perfect. Not good, not competent, perfect. Because Europe adds games, travel, rotation demands, and the sort of physical toll that punishes thin squads like a debt collector.
You can already see the shopping list forming, and it is not the little weekend errand list, it is the big one you avoid because you know what it costs. Another striker, because you cannot live on “hopefully” across four competitions. A left winger, because width and threat cannot be optional. Arguably a left back and a right back, because modern football is ruthless about fullbacks who can run, defend, and contribute. Two central midfielders, including someone genuinely elite to replace Casemiro as the miles stack up. Probably another center back if Harry Maguire leaves, because depth is not a luxury, it is survival.
This is how you set up the next manager for failure. You hand them a thin squad, you ask them to chase Europe, you tell them to “compete,” then you make them do all the heavy lifting in one window. It is an organizational habit, this craving for drama, this addiction to the late fix, this idea that you can patch a ship mid-storm and still blame the captain when the water gets in.
January was the chance to lighten the load. To add one serious piece, to buy breathing room, to show the dressing room that ambition is not a slogan. Instead, INEOS have chosen the same old United ritual, cross your fingers, grit your teeth, and hope the bill does not come due until somebody else is holding the clipboard.
Be the first to comment